By the end of episode 2 if you're not into it then I don't think you're going to get into it. I mean the big draw about the show really is how well they did with the look and the feel of everything. It just sounds like you don't appreciate the premise, which is fine not all shows are for everybody.
this post was submitted on 18 Aug 2024
33 points (83.7% liked)
movies
1495 readers
679 users here now
Warning: If the community is empty, make sure you have "English" selected in your languages in your account settings.
A community focused on discussions on movies. Besides usual movie news, the following threads are welcome
- Discussion threads to discuss about a specific movie or show
- Weekly threads: what have you been watching lately?
- Trailers
- Posters
- Retrospectives
- Should I watch?
Related communities:
Show communities:
Discussion communities:
RULES
Spoilers are strictly forbidden in post titles.
Posts soliciting spoilers (endings, plot elements, twists, etc.) should contain [spoilers] in their title. Comments in these posts do not need to be hidden in spoiler MarkDown if they pertain to the title’s subject matter.
Otherwise, spoilers but must be contained in MarkDown.
2024 discussion threads
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
It just sounds like you don’t appreciate the premise, which is fine not all shows are for everybody.
Thing is, I think I’m rather fond of the general premise, at least as I understand it. I really liked Silo for instance.
I suspect it’s more that I’m completely disconnected from the video game adaptation aspect of it and probably not even into the aesthetic and vibe of a video game adaptation.
“I loved Brokeback Mountain but find these John Wayne movies not to my taste”
Sounds like you like the setting - post apocalyptic - not necessarily the premise. Fallout is about the offbeat humour and violence. Silo is completely different (I loved Silo too).
I know pllllllllenty of people who don’t like Andor. They found it either “too Star Wars-y” or “not Star Wars-y enough”.
The world would be a boring place if we all liked the same things.
Fallout is about the offbeat humour and violence.
I am not at all opposed to offbeat humour and violence! Rather fond of it actually.
The part from the top post I think you're missing/under-emphasising is my sense that the show feels somewhat empty and awkward. I'm only two episodes in of course, but others in this thread seem to understand where I'm coming from, so I don't think it's just a misaligned tastes thing. The season apparently hits its stride as it goes though, so I'll probably persevere
And I wasn't suggesting that I was expecting a show just like Andor, from that comparison I was only expecting something surprisingly good. And to be clear, I'm not suggesting it's a bad show or anything, just sharing how I'm not vibing with it and curious why.
I've played the games.
The show sucks - I couldn't even finish the first episode. There's no connection to the characters.
Interestingly opposed to others' impression that game players generally liked the show!
The big thing about the show, and the games is the moral ambiguity of it. It's captured in a line that maximus says in episode 2? Or 3? Where he says "everyone wants to save the world. They just disagree how to do it." It's an important line because everyone has their own way of dealing with the wasteland, which isn't inherently wrong all the time. And if you watch the ghoul, you'll see there's a lot more depth to him than being a comedic psychopath. Give it a little more time and you'll connect with the characters more. Less so with Lucy, but I think she's there more as a blank slate, to show how the world can change an otherwise good person.
SILO FUCKIN REPRESENT
ok I'll shut up now
lol, I’m here for it! I probably like that show too much, but don’t care.
There's a lot of world-building going on in the first 2-3 episodes, and story lines start slowly drawing together after that point. It doesn't really come together until the final episode, and that is something that's clearly leaving a lot of room for a second season.
Yes, it helps if you understand the context that it's all taking place in; playing the games (particularly 3, New Vegas, and 4) is very helpful to knowing some of the context that isn't stated explicitly, but not strictly necessary.
Despite having a ton of action and violence, the plot is a fairly slow burn, and takes a while to get to the critical parts where everything really comes together. Things seem straightforward, until you realize that they aren't.
Things seem straightforward, until you realize that they aren’t.
Cheers! This makes sense.
Why is this in movies shouldn't it be in television?
That is totally fair!
This community was originally intended to be for both movies and TV, but it was a bit redundant and so we took focus off of TV. I did a search around for Fallout discussions and didn't find anything in the sort of critical vein of my post, and it's old enough that it falls under "discussion" more than anything news etc, so I thought it could make sense here. Happy to be criticised for this. But I feel like it'd make sense to allow retrospective "slow" TV discussion back into this community while disallowing latest TV news and trailers and the like ... but I'm not speaking as a mod at all on this, just riffing. I like the people here and like discussing things here is all!
Thing is, I've played most of the games, and I feel no connection to the characters, feel no reason to continue even after the first episode and I could barely get through that.
It's all melodrama, nothing more, sadly.
I don't see how someone who's never played the games would find even the first episode intruiging enough to watch more.
You should watch till like the 4th episode I'd say. There is a lot happening that doesn't have context until a bit later one. It's an excellent story, but it is a slow burn.
I've never played any of the games
Thanks for this! I'll watch until the 4th episode!
There should be a mechanism for the poster to appoint a comment as the "answer" to a question
I've played the games, and really enjoyed the show; but I'll admit it took a bit of time to find its path.
The thing about Fallout is that it's deadpan tongue-in-cheek, which is hard to pull off. They got there in time.
And if you don't start to get into it after a few more episodes, don't sweat it.
Cheers! This makes sense and what I was wondering! It had real “finding its feet” vibes, where I can see it tightening up.
I do wonder if Jon Nolan’s directing is a factor here (he directed the first 3 eps).
Everyone I know who enjoyed it also played the games and was onboard by like halfway through the first episode. You probably just don't get it without the added context of the aesthetics and humor of the games.
i loved the show and didn’t play the games….
well, i played the free vault overseer mobile one…
I watched 3 episodes and thought it felt oddly lopsided. I really liked the scenery and environments but the writing just bad.
Yea, this is where I was at. Not vibing with something happens. But once I thought about the writing, I realised something may have been objectively off here.
Ya there’s a fair amount of spectacle involved. People who played the games dig it more I think and it’s honestly made with a lot of love, but don’t feel bad if it don’t grab you. I felt similarly to the way you describe, finished it nevetheless.
Thanks!
I would say give episode 3 a fair shot. I was in a similar mindset to you, but came around to the show. There are some dumb decisions made by the show in my opinion, but don't want to spoil anything for you.
Cheers! I was thinking of giving ep 3 a shot too. Least I can do.
I think there will be some nice twists and mystery for you later on. If it's not your thing, it's not your thing of course.
I agree on the emptiness. I also felt like they were trying too hard with a lot of scenes, and I had a hard time relating to the characters. However, it got more interesting as the story and the world open up more.
Having played the games, and having liked them, the series was a welcome and fitting extension of the existing narrative. It fits so well into the universe, that you will happily forgive any shortcomings, just to get this pleasant enrichment to prior experiences. Watching the show is almost like you're back in the wasteland yourself, discovering it all over again.
It does not feel like a cheap abuse of a brand you associate with a good time. That alone is worth a lot.
I also felt like the HDR video and Atmos audio are well done and contribute to the impact of the show, as available of course.
There were twists in the story I did not anticipate. Maybe it's just my interpretation, but the way the series tells its story felt overly video game like. You always follow the protagonists closely on their linear progress through their active quest, and the breaks in that progress feel so clearly like side quests. I couldn't put my finger on it, but I felt that was well done.
After all, it is a series that builds on existing material, which is video games. The way they implemented it is highly consistent with your prior experience and people appreciate that greatly.
I love the games (haven't played 76, but the rest are great). I watched the first 3 episodes and thought they connected well with the games thematically, but I never cared enough to continue. Every now and then I think I should get back to it, but I always have something that interests me more, including just scrolling Lemmy. To be fair, I don't really enjoy watching TV or movies that much though.
Nah. It’s not that good. It’s novel, but I don’t think quite nails it.
Show does pick up in the second half of the season imo