this post was submitted on 01 Dec 2024
30 points (87.5% liked)
artporn
4039 readers
21 users here now
Wander the gallery. Look at the art. Be polite. If you feel able please post some great art :)
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
The sky was never as beautiful as it was before 1492
Fuck this shit showing my ancestors as the darkness being pushed away.
Fucking right, this isn't artporn, it's propaganda
It is. But it seemed a good time to remind the younger generation of how art can be used to push agendas in a very negative way. I expected a lot of discussion, which is one of the purposes of art.
If this doesn't belong here, just downvote it folks and I'll remove it.
Well, I can't downvote from my instance, and I wouldn't anyway. The discourse is more important. Now that I know your purpose was the discussion, I'm much more inclined to upvote and add more to the discussion.
It's total propaganda, but viewing it now, I see it as a picture of the story Americans tell. Their shitty ideas of progress are highlighted - pollution, cars, use and abuse of the land.
In the shadow of all this, hidden in the dark on the corner of the painting that they're all moving towards, is genocide, murder, killing of buffalos, and the eradication of wildlife.
"American Progress" sounds like a dark joke - like a greasy canteen pizza being labeleld "American vegetable".
Of course, this was not the intention of the painter, and generations of white Americans have looked at this painting and completely ignored the story that is really being told. But it's all there, laid bare, and there's no use pretending they weren't aware of what they were doing.
And for that, at least it has some value. It's like gathering evidence of war crimes from the offenders bragging about their atrocities. Anyone who proudly hung this on their wall you know what they knew, and you know where they stood.
That said, what a shitty piece of work. It's a crime against good taste depicting a crime against humanity.